Okechukwu Nwanguma
Sunday Ifedi returned home after four years in detention without charge. Only then did he learn that his wife, Calista, who had been taken from their home alongside him, had died in custody. Stephen Kenechi’s 16 November report for The New Humanitarian traces the couple’s detention to the military-run Wawa facility in Niger State.
It reports that the Department of State Services cleared Sunday and that a DSS review panel reportedly acknowledged that Calista should never have been detained. Her family still does not know where she is buried.
How many more people were wrongfully arrested and held incommunicado for months or years? How many were denied medical care? How many died in custody while their families were still searching for them? The Federal Government owes Nigerians a verified answer. It has access to the arrest records, transfer logs and detention registers that families have spent years trying to see. It should reconcile those records against missing-person reports and account for each person whose trail ends in state custody.
At RULAAC’s October press conference in Enugu, The Missing, the Detained and the Dead, families described searching for relatives across agencies and detention facilities. Every time an agency denies custody or fails to document a transfer, a family loses a lead. A lawyer may have nowhere to serve a court order. A detainee who needs urgent treatment can deteriorate beyond the reach of anyone who might intervene. That is what makes an accurate custody register, prompt notification of relatives and access to counsel matters of life and death.
*Who must answer?*
The Attorney-General of the Federation should initiate an independent investigation into the Ifedis’ case and a wider review of credible reports of secret detention. The DSS, the military, the police and the Nigerian Correctional Service should be required to produce the records necessary to trace people from arrest through every transfer, release or death in custody. Preservation orders should cover custody registers, transfer logs, medical files, duty rosters, mortuary records and burial records. Independent investigators should have access to Wawa and every other facility credibly identified in complaints, with a secure way for detainees, relatives and officers to give evidence. In Calista’s case, the authorities should establish how she died, locate and identify her remains, and return them to her family.
Investigators should establish who authorised the arrests, who approved continued detention, who handled requests for medical care and what each supervising officer knew or did. Where the evidence supports charges, prosecutors should bring them. Where it establishes disciplinary breaches, the responsible authorities should act on them and report the outcome. Nigeria’s Anti-Torture Act provides for liability where a superior orders torture and where an immediate commander’s act, omission or negligence leads to torture by subordinates. Establishing who made the decisions matters as much as identifying who carried them out.
*Who gets a remedy?*
Sunday Ifedi is owed an account of his detention and an effective remedy. Section 35(6) of the Constitution entitles a person unlawfully arrested or detained to compensation and a public apology from the appropriate authority or person. In practice, a survivor may also need medical and psychological care, help rebuilding a livelihood and assistance with the legal costs of securing redress. Where courts award compensation, the responsible authorities must pay it.
Families have suffered harm in their own right. They have spent money searching, lived with years of uncertainty and, in some cases, lost the income on which their households depended. Under the UN Convention on Enforced Disappearance, to which Nigeria acceded in 2009, the definition of a victim includes anyone directly harmed by the disappearance. The Convention recognises victims’ rights to truth and reparation, and requires the state to search for the missing and return their remains where they have died. The National Assembly should give these protections full effect in domestic law, including a clear route for survivors and families to obtain compensation and rehabilitation. In 2023, the UN Committee on Enforced Disappearances had already called on Nigeria to strengthen its searches and improve its detention registers. The Federal Government can act on those recommendations now.
Can the wrong ever be righted? Sunday cannot recover those four years, and Calista’s children cannot have their mother back. But they can still be told who took her, what happened to her in custody and where she was buried. They can receive reparations. Those responsible can face justice. And for a person still alive in undisclosed custody, an independent search carried out today may mean getting medical care, seeing a lawyer or coming home. That is the most urgent reason for the government to account for every person it has taken into custody.
By Okechukwu Nwanguma, Executive Director, Rule of Law and Accountability Advocacy Centre (RULAAC)